Ask Lemmy

Upvoting: I like this post or it adds to the discussion/community (I want to see more of this)

Downvoting: This is spam, off topic, etc. or the poster is being an arse (in general, I want to see less of this)

Simple as.

Upvote: contributes positively to the discussion, hasnt been said before in the same thread, well researched/high effort

Downvote: trolling, obvious/overdone, bad/disingenuous reasoning, spreads misinformation, bigotry/sexism

"Do you wish there were more content like this?" Upvote.

"Do you wish there were less content like this?" Downvote.

I downvote for people being assholes (trolling, bigotry, ad hominem, etc), spreading misinformation, or making comments which don't add to the conversation ("This.", "This is the way."), and rarely for anything else.

I upvote content that I find interesting, educational, funny, etc. I also upvote people for being polite and willing to admit to being incorrect ("Thanks for the information, I didn't know that", etc).

Up: more people should read this

Down: less people should have to read this

I tend to agree about the down cote it if you disagree with it. I tend to just leave the thread or try not to comment to avoid silly online arguments.

However, if I read something posted that is obviously misleading or someone is just outright lying, then downvote away!

I tend to upvote if someone brings something unique to the discussion. If you're just giving a quick generic response to OP or parroting the same opinion a dozen other people in the thread have already posted, then I'm gonna read your comment and keep going. But if you provide thoughtful content that promotes discussion, provides a unique perspective, or at least had a lot of thought put into it, I'm likely to upvote it. Same goes for the post itself.

I generally avoid downvoting, even if I disagree with the comment. But if someone is factually wrong, misleading, posting in bad faith, or just being a troll, I'll downvote their comments in a thread and upvote anyone who attempts to be reasonable with them. If two people are just bickering back and forth, they both get downvotes. And as always, any comments that distract from the discussion or are off-topic will get a downvote.

If it contributed to the conversation, I upvote. Especially if it's well-written and informative.

If it's off-topic, incorrect, or repetitive, I downvote.

If it's banal or uninteresting but not actually deleterious to discourse or distracting from the topic, I don't vote.

I upvote almost all replies to my comments, including those disagreeing with me, unless they clearly didn't take the time to read and understand my comment.

I vote on almost all comments I reply to, as well.

If you reply to my comment or post, it’s an automatic upvote because I appreciate you for taking the time to interact with me and I will try to reply in return.
If a post or comment is funny, touching, interesting, heartfelt or anything else that makes me appreciate the time and effort you put into this, it’s an upvote.
If you’re only here to argue in bad faith, insult or belittle someone, it’s a downvote. If it’s with me, I will ignore you and not even downvote.

I like this: upvote

I don't like this: downvote

I generally don't downvote anything. I, however, upvote stuff other people might want to see first. Easy as that.

"Reddiquette" that included guidelines about upvoting and downvoting.

First time that I even hear about that LOL.

I do not follow any 'guidelines' when up/downvoting. It comes spontaneously.

I try to upvote most things I see, especially if someone took the time to comment under one of my posts.

If I downvote, it's usually because I see someone is actively being rude or is trying to steer something light into something controversial to bait arguments.

If I like it, I upvote. If I dislike it, I downvote. If I have no strong feelings, I do nothing. If I commented and it got a lot of upvotes, I return the favor and upvote the post and any decent comments.

I upvote any reply to anything I say and everything I reply to as a way of remembering where I've engaged. The only exceptions are things with clear perspective-lacking malice.

Upvote for funny posts, posts that contribute to the discussion even if they drift a bit off topic, and anything that promotes positivity.

No upvotes/downvites for things I disagree with that are just differences in opinions, or something that is trying to be funny but doesn't work for me. Also posts I just don't understand or understand the context.

Downvotes for people being jerks, posting misinformation, promoting terrible stuff like fascism, racism, sexism, etc. It does mean I mostly downvote anything positive about US conservatives, but that is because they tend to promote those things I mentioned already.

I sometimes also downvote people who go overboard with generally positive things by assuming anything other than agreeing with their narrow view is automatically malicious. Some of us are trying and admitting we aren't perfect or that maybe there is more than one way to be supportive than the one they think the only way.

Upvote if I find the post good and remember it exists, downvote disabled

my instance has downvotes disabled - it allows me to move on with my life. Only upping just seems more zen

I'm pretty liberal with the upvotes. I like to encourage people to participate and an upvote feels like saying "hey I see you and thanks for sharing." I regularly upvote things I don't like or don't agree with, if they are shared in good faith and contribute to the conversation.

Downvotes are for bigots and misinformation/disinformation/lies.

downvotes are for condescension and things people already mentioned

You guys have a downvote? Whoa, here on .one we do not.

For posts:

Interesting content gets updoot. Spam, misinformation, and conservative politics get the downdoot.

For comments:

Relevant to the discussion (be it top-level or deep in a thread), funny, and factual statements get updoots. Irrelevant comments, false information, poor argumentative skills, and conservative political get the downdoot.

I was never a reddit member and so may miss some of that nuance, but I vote for things I enjoyed reading or for folks I enjoyed interacting with. I thought about down voting one thing, but then leaned that group didn't work that way. The whole point was to say something that was against the grain.

Upvote: it is the same thing I was going to comment, or it is an extraordinarily good post that stands out from the masses

Downvote: it is objectively wrong or doesn't add to the discussion at all

Vast majority of everything, I neither upvote nor downvote.

Generally, it's based on appropriateness to the C/, effort, and usefulness.

There are exceptions, though there aren't any on C/s that I actually use. But there might be eventually, there were on reddit.

If something doesn't fit the C/, that's a down vote if I notice it.

If something is horribly low effort, even if it's in the right place, that'll be a down vote.

Upvotes, it tends to be because something was appropriate to the C/, and/or someone put some work in. But, even a low effort post/comment can get an up vote if it's personally useful.

I used to up vote anything and everything that was on topic, but lemmy has gotten busy enough that I tend to only vote at all if I interact with the post in some way. So, like a title that indicates the post isn't something that will interest me, I just scroll past because there's just so much stuff now. But, I scroll All, and sort by new by default, so I end up scrolling past stuff that isn't in my subscription list. If I only scrolled through subscribed stuff, I'd probably end up voting the same amount, but voting on everything I saw, if that makes sense.

Downvotes are for off topic or inflammatory comments, not for things you disagree with, in my opinion.

I let lurkers do the upvoting or downvoting unless it's really good or really bad Downvotes don't federate from or to kbin anyway.

I neither upvote nor downvote stuff.

I'm afraid it's the same algorithm I use to answer the question whether I need a receipt.

"Glad i saw that" -> up-vote, "Wish i didn't see that" -> down-vote

I'm not sure if this is just another way of saying what others have said, but I also upvote if something accomplished the theme of the community. The example that comes to mind is from the other site, but if something on r/mademesmile actually made me smile, I upvoted. As for downvotes, I usually save them for posts that I want to be less visible for whatever reason. Sometimes that is because I disagree sometimes it is because they are reposts, or low effort trolling, etc. Right or wrong, that's how I do it.

I don't vote very much because that's just too much responsibility for me to handle.

My personal rules

Up = Like it, interesting novel take (even if I disagree), funny and clever

No vote with comment = disagree but worthwhile discussing, unintentional but incorrect and/or misleading info.

Down = Spam, low effort to the point it's insulting (clearly not reading beyond the title), flaming and flamebaiting (this is a big one on forums like this everywhere), trolling, intentionally incorrect or misleading information, off-topic/irrelevant stuff.

Report = hate speech, violence against members of our communities, incessant trolling or flaming or flamebaiting (more than twice in a row).