Karma is nothing more than fake internet points. When I tire of this persona or decide I'd rather make my home on another instance, I'll just spin up a new name wholly unrelated to the old name.
this post was submitted on 23 Dec 2023
47 points (89.8% liked)
Asklemmy
43909 readers
970 users here now
A loosely moderated place to ask open-ended questions
Search asklemmy ๐
If your post meets the following criteria, it's welcome here!
- Open-ended question
- Not offensive: at this point, we do not have the bandwidth to moderate overtly political discussions. Assume best intent and be excellent to each other.
- Not regarding using or support for Lemmy: context, see the list of support communities and tools for finding communities below
- Not ad nauseam inducing: please make sure it is a question that would be new to most members
- An actual topic of discussion
Looking for support?
Looking for a community?
- Lemmyverse: community search
- sub.rehab: maps old subreddits to fediverse options, marks official as such
- !lemmy411@lemmy.ca: a community for finding communities
~Icon~ ~by~ ~@Double_A@discuss.tchncs.de~
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
I'd rather prefer to keep my comments simply for the information.
I've learned to save stuff in a file on a cloud. I've learned the hard way so many times that I cannot rely on Reddit or Lemmy to guarantee I will always be able to access everything I've saved in my accounts.
Oh, I will definitely save important lemmy pages with archive.org
Specific information if possible will be saved to my obsidian.md vault
Also it sometimes happens that I get a reply to some pretty old comment.
Yeah, I get that. I treated my reddit account like that. My reddit account was 15 years old and you can do some sleuthing and doxxing and track down my real name if you're persistent enough. Nowadays I value privacy a bit more, so I just save important stuff to my second brain (these days it's in Obsidian.md, but I'm not married to a specific app).
I used to do that in Reddit. In Lemmy I just deactivate the voting system indicators.
So far there is only (officially) the ability to export account settings, not the content itself.
Didn't the GDPR have a data portability rule requiring that sites provide users the ability to easily export their own data? Does that not apply to Lemmy for some reason -- or, am I misremembering it? (I remember account data download being a big deal a while back on reddit, but it's been a few years...)
Lemmy is a small FOSS project ultimately, not a corporate entity. If anyone got penalized, it'd probably be the instance host owner at the end of the day. I'm sure they'd be willing to add this feature if someone added it for them, but they got plenty on their plate. If you desperately wanted to for some reason, you might be able to convince the instance owner to export your info from the DB lol, but it's not even worth the effort.
I think it's more about being prepared for potential attack using loads of GDPR requests that definitely can't get processed manually even in 30 days. You know, just like we did with Reddit a few months ago.
Yeah, Lemmy and the GDPR is just an accident waiting to happen. I suppose somebody could just write a script to extract the requested information from the (PostgreSQL?) database. And share that script with other admins. But there are other parts of the GDPR that we also don't pay any attention to.
The regulation does not apply to the processing of data by a person for a "purely personal or household activity and thus with no connection to a professional or commercial activity." (Recital 18)
Considering most servers are run by volunteers, it's unlikely the EU will try to enforce it.
However it would be nice to have the feature, and Mastodon does have the feature to export your data to ActivityPub format.
Is that working now, though? Last time I heard you can't transfer messages between servers as well on Masto. Would be amazing if it's possible now!
You can't transfer but you can at least archive.
The issue I could see is ill-intentioned users importing a modified archive to alter the publication date to make it appear they posted something at a specific date in the past when they in fact didn't.
This kind of functionality is something nostr does natively, but lemmy doesn't really have a solution for this problem yet.
Yeah well, I thought of maybe attaching a public key to all the messages and then when a user gives a instance a signed challenge the instance wanted, then the instance could allow the user to take ownership of these messages with that public key. But I guess only the nostr protocol does something similar, Lemmy doesn't do it yet.
Lemmy 0.19.0 and higher have an export button in the web interface settings that'll back up most of the stuff on your account. If your instance isn't on that version yet, you'll have to wait for the admins to upgrade.
I'm not sure if likes are transferred, as those are propagated across the network, but saved posts and comments should be, I think. In theory you could write a tool to download all data from your Lemmy account for earlier versions of Lemmy by using the API, but that'll be much slower to generate.
If you're an EU citizen, you could also demand a digitally readable data export of all your personal data from your instance admins through the rights granted to you under the GDPR and have them deal with it, but I don't think you'll make any friends by doing that.
Lemmy 0.19.0 and higher have an export button in the web interface settings that'll back up most of the stuff on your account. If your instance isn't on that version yet, you'll have to wait for the admins to upgrade.
I used this to migrate my account from my old instance - it carries over your subscriptions, blocked communities, blocked users, saved posts, saved comments, display name, profile description, and theme applied ๐
Pretty much everything you'd want, except your own posts and your own comments, but those don't matter to me too much.
People on lemmy.world (running lemmy 0.18.5) will need to use something else to migrate their account, like lasim: https://github.com/CMahaff/lasim
Pretty much everything you'd want, except your own posts and your own comments, but those don't matter to me too much.
In a perfect world, you could migrate all this content and keep your points and comments.
Unfortunately, this would be abused so hard. We would have people setting up private instances, faking their databases and creating accounts with a million Karma and huge comment histories. Then taking those personas and importing them onto legit instances.
This isn't an issue with today's Lemmy. But down the track if Lemmy is the size of Reddit, scammers and spammers would be doing this to, well scam and spam.
I wish we could just trust everyone. That sounds like a nicer world.