by Centurii-chan
this post was submitted on 15 Aug 2024
470 points (100.0% liked)
196
16297 readers
2957 users here now
Be sure to follow the rule before you head out.
Rule: You must post before you leave.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
What are the weaknesses/strengths of using a spear over a halberd?
From here, it looks like the halberd is almost just a straight upgrade from a spear, except for the depth that spears can stab.
In an unarmored context, which applied very often throughout history, the spear is easier to use and especially lighter, which makes it a better and more nimble weapon. Spears can also be much longer than heavier pole arms whilst remaining usable, keeping the danger further away from the user
The speed at which one can move a spear tip is impressive and getting stabbed by it has large stopping power. The spear can also parry attacks in a large sweeping area, which makes it hard for anything else than another spear to get through
The more complex pole weapons start to shine in an armored context, where stabbing someone at the end of your long pointy stick becomes harder. Then, the hook-y, chop-y and spike-y bits of the halberd can really help tackle the armor
A truly determined (re: suicidal) person can also just impale themselves further on your spear to disarm you. Can't do that against a halberd.
Shield walls help with this problem as well though, so spears are still really versatile.
The boar technique
Exactly what I was thinking about (read a post about that the other day on how boars are so batshit crazy they'll impale themselves further just to try to gore you)
Spears are also easier to make, so you can make them faster.
So basically it's a numbers game
Yeah halberds are more versatile and can be incredibly effective, but you can equip a lot of dudes with spears and less training.
At least that's my understanding
While the halberd's blade offers a lot of options for hooking your opponent, it equally gives them an opportunity to hook your polearm and manipulate it themselves. The simpler spearhead is also lighter than that of a halberd, allowing for more sustain when fighting for long periods.
I would definitely prefer a halberd (or billhook) over a spear given the choice, but it's not as much of a direct upgrade as you might think.
I just read about swiss mercenaries a while ago and wondered the whole read why they didn't have a short range weapon like a knife or axe too. Probably because of this.
Btw, they needed a whole century to equip the army with spears. Things sure moved slower back then.