email is an extremely important technology to start supporting for privacy and freedom
No: email, even when encrypted, leaks plenty of metadata. From a privacy perspective it has been a lost cause for decades. We need new protocols.
this post was submitted on 21 Feb 2022
1 points (66.7% liked)
Libre Culture
4376 readers
4 users here now
What is libre culture?
Libre culture is all about empowering people. While the general philosophy stems greatly from the free software movement, libre culture is much broader and encompasses other aspects of culture such as music, movies, food, technology, etc.
Some beliefs include but aren't limited to:
- That copyright should expire after a certain period of time.
- That knowledge should be available to people, not locked away.
- That no entity should have unjust control or possession of others.
- That mass surveillance is about mass control, not justice.
- That we can all band together to help liberate each other.
Check out this link for more.
Rules
I've looked into the ways other forums handle rules, and I've distilled their policies down into two simple ideas.
-
Please show common courtesy: Let's make this community one that people want to be a part of.
-
Please keep posts generally on topic
-
No NSFW content
-
When sharing a Libre project, please include the name of its license in the title. For example: “Project name and summary (GPL-3.0)”
Libre culture is a very very broad topic, and while it's perfectly okay for a conversation to stray, I do ask that we keep things generally on topic.
Related Communities
- Libre Culture Memes
- Open Source
- ActivityPub
- Linux
- BSD
- Free (libre) Software Replacements
- Libre Software
- Libre Hardware
Helpful Resources
- The Respects Your Freedom Certification
- Libre GNU/Linux Distros
- Wikimedia Foundation
- The Internet Archive
- Guide to DRM-Free Living
- LibreGameWiki
- switching.software
- How to report violations of the GNU licenses
- Creative Commons Licenses
Community icon is from Wikimedia Commons and is public domain.
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
Whether fit for purpose working receive email addresses are a requirement to obtain many services. I should be more precise though, if we are creating services that we want to be usable with privacy, then we should not support email as a requirement for use. Since the case is that many services do require email, I mean to focus here on supporting this anonymous email facility.
I think tox might be a good fit.
Are there even any candidates at the moment? What would a next gen email look like, one that didn't leak metadata?
Matrix is the successor to email. Open spec, encryption-first design, federated, much easier to self host and possibly p2p in the future.
It leaks plenty of metadata. Also it's hardly easy to self-host.
How do you avoid leaking metadata to your server in a federated system?
By using onion routing to connect to it, as Briar does. Also by not having a server at all, again as Briar does.
Briar's server is the app itself, all federation metadata concerns also apply to p2p federation. Your briar app leaks metadata to every other device it talks with.
I don't think that is true. Matrix could be the successor to mailing lists, as it has interesting properties (anti-censorship, consensus-building) for that usecase. But so far matrix implementations are too reliant on huge databases to become practical... I hope the situation continues to improve in the coming years.
Link please, most of the search results for that don't seem to be what you're referring to.
And isn't there a way to sign into things with Matrix? Like OAuth? I thought I heard of that somewhere.
No matrix has its own auth system for signing into it. But more importantly they have bridges that can connect matrix rooms to other services, like IRC, xmpp, etc.
Does the matrix protocol even enable an inbox-message-delivery type of communication similar to email, or is it all about room synchronisation?
At least with the current clients even a 1to1 chat is a room state synchronised across the involved servers, and doesn't lend itself to managing messages in an inbox very well.
Its even better than email in that regard, you have to accept a message request before they can spam you. And it looks really no different from email, with a list of conversations being equivalent to your inbox.
Briar is a good example.
I know this isn't super helpful in answering your question, but it would be nice if we didn't need to rely on technology like email for account creation at all. The domain name provider njalla allows for account creation using an XMPP address, and the VPN provider mullvad generates a random string of numbers as your username. If only the rest of the web followed suit.
Right. It's not just about the question but looking a little deeper to get to what it means to have a free culture. What's required. What would be done differently. This was just a specific challenge that made sense to step back a little from. If there's a principle it should be honesty about why identifying information is required and looking for alternatives.
Protonmail doesn't require an email or phone number. It just requiers your IP address for sign up
Hosting your own receive only email is not so difficult, so you can use that for signing up on all sorts of services and forward messages to a XMPP address that looks the same.
When people complain that you never reply, just tell them to contact you through xmpp ;)
See table "Email Hosting market share table" https://www.datanyze.com/market-share/email-hosting--23
Google has 34% market share, Microsoft has 30%, GoDaddy has 15%, and the other 6 providers on that top 10 list are all under 3% each. 3 private, for-profit corporations handle 79% of all email.
If you want to re-decentralize email, and the web overall, you have to figure out what to do about the increasing concentration of Internet infra into an ever-smaller number of hands. I'm guessing there is not a technical solution to this.
I’m guessing there is not a technical solution to this
We need dead simple turn key solutions for self hosted services. Simple as setting up a wifi router or some other consumer focused device.
Users get to use networks on terms dictated by their ISP's. My ISP blocks self-hosted email. They did so because it was not in their interest -- spammers were using the functionality to run spam ops. They still allow for self-hosting, but as self-hosting becomes more popular, ISPs' residential networks are going to become a security minefield and an increasing liability. They will tighten the screws on what people are allowed to self-host and how, or they'll just make it painful to impossible.
You could do a "self-hosted" turnkey email VPS, I guess, but then the users have to rent and spin up VPS's.
We need dead simple turn key solutions for self hosted services.
Does anyone have experience with FreedomBox? (https://freedombox.org/)
It looks very interesting...