Of course the story we've come up with has started to unravel. It was essentially destined to, just as all the past stories we've come up with have. We're just the tiniest little splash in the tiniest little pan way off in some obscure corner of a reality that is vast and complex beyond comprehension.
To think that we can understand the nature of the universe, much less that we already do, is and always has been startlingly obviously ludicrous.