this post was submitted on 12 Jun 2023
59 points (100.0% liked)
Meta
729 readers
35 users here now
Yhteisö instanssia koskeville tiedotuksille, palautteelle, metakeskustelulle ja avulle. Katso myös UKK!
Community for announcements regarding the instance, feedback, meta discussion and help. Check the FAQ also!
Users needing support can also come to our Matrix Space.
Tukea tarvitsevat käyttäjät voivat myös tulla Matrix-tilaamme.
founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
What I don't understand though. What was the reason for Kbin to be developed since we already have Lemmy as a Reddit alternative?
There seems to be consternation about "lemmygrad" and certain Mastodon users have decried Lemmy because the developer also runs "lemmygrad".
Also this https://imgs.xkcd.com/comics/standards.png
It's so stupid. Though right now it seems kbin is federating better with Mastodon vis-a-vis the UX? Not tried it out yet but if true, that might be another reason.
great meme
I had never heard of kbin before the Reddit shitstorm began.
Kbin seems to be AGPL3 software targeting ActivityPub, so ultimately it doesn't matter, they're joining us rest. Seems like it's written in PHP so it could at least attract different contributors than what Lemmy would.
My understanding is it's all the same thing? Lemmy, kbin, mastodon are all fediverse? So we can join any and see all of them?
Not quite. Different things speaking (partially) the same language, ActivityPub.
I think Lemmy can't see Mastodon, and using Mastodon to browse Lemmy is suboptimal. Kbin is the only app layer that can work "ok" with both.
AFAIK, its USP is that it combines Lemmy community's and Mastodon hastags into magazines, which makes it easier to peruse certain subjects (if you're interested in microblogging). Also, the server handles a lot of the technical aspects of finding and subscribing to communities. So you can just follow a magazine about gaming instead of having to subsceibe to all the gaming communities you can find. The downsides are that you give away a lot of agency to a third party (and we know how that can end). Also, AFAIK the Kbin interface displays a lot of personal information, like your upvotes and subscriptions. It seems very oriented to following people over communities.
Kbin users do contribute to Lemmy communities and vice versa, so that is great. Personally, I feel Kbin adds a bit of bloat to the Lemmy experience, with the hashtags and complicated topic headers and all. But that is a minor annoyance.