You want to call it false at the same time you admit that these systems are predatory? You can't do both at once. What you are really saying is that you believe the exploitation is worth the longevity.

If anything the cosmetics second hand market is proof that something is wrong, when people resell a skin for over a thousand dollars. No in-game item is worth that much, and people only convince themselves it is because their scarcity is controlled for financial gain.

Mind you, I said it myself DLC is fine when done properly so you are not even acknowledging the options that I'm mentioning. Games can be maintained without microtransaction. Your response isn't even directed at me, but the vague sentiment that you get from the thread in general.

And even on their case, there is something to be said in favor of games you can host yourself indefinitely, rather than relying on company servers that are locked down to sell microtransactions. What good is a game that is updated for a few years and then is gone forever? Even the ones who supported it intently are left with nothing. That's the fate of the majority of freemium games.