Old. They're being old. This is EXACTLY the same energy as a boomer saying "Music these days don't get it" or "No one pays attention to this anymore" or "Nothing's as good as it used to be".

The take hyper focuses on negativity and would rather whine and complain about everything bad NOW, while nostalgia is living in their head rent free, because things are passing them by.

A friend of mine started saying BG3 was garbage recently. When I asked why he couldn't adequately get out a reason. They were all weird and dismissive. We ended up in a heated discussion because I felt he wasn't being fair at all to the game. Turns out I was right. He eventually ended up saying "Listen I just think the game fucking sucks because there is too much in it. I don't have the time for all this. I miss when games were good and didn't sprawl on forever, forcing you to get confused and lost." When I pointed out that his complaint was based entirely in what he likes and not what's good, he changed subject.

Nine times out of ten these "IT'S NOT GOOD ANYMORE" are based purely in nostalgia that ignores everything negative because they're not looking to criticize. They're looking to vent their frustrations but don't know how to do it in a healthy or fair manner.