Risa

The target audience doesn't effect my point at all

But it does. Your point was that it's "not a defense". My point was "they're not trying to defend". Your rebuttal here is "They're still not defending."

At no point in that image does Troi make a defense for her own abilities. She says that people complain about her and then goes onto Vader. So yes. She's distracting, not defending, but she was never claiming to make a defense in the first place. That does affect your point pretty significantly.